Probation isn't a checkbox - it's where performance and culture begin
Probation periods often get treated as a box to tick: contracts signed, forms completed, review done. But when handled well, probation can be one of the most powerful tools you have to build strong performance and a positive workplace culture.
Those first few months matter. They shape how people feel about their role, their manager and your organisation - often for years to come.
Here are 10 practical ways to make probation periods work harder for your people and your business.
Think of probation as “recruitment part two”
Hiring doesn’t end on day one. Probation is where role fit and cultural fit are truly tested.
It’s also a two-way street. New employees are asking themselves: Is this what I signed up for? Can I see a future here?Treat probation as a shared decision-making period, not just an assessment.
Remember you’re employing a whole person
A new job isn’t just a role - it’s someone’s livelihood, routine and often their family’s stability.
Yes, policies and compliance matter, but so does helping people feel welcomed, supported and confident. Sometimes that’s as simple as knowing who to ask for help or where to find a pen on day one.
Put leaders in the driver’s seat
Probation isn’t a HR task; it’s a leadership responsibility.
HR should provide the framework and support, but day-to-day probation management sits with leaders. Like any skill, it works best when leaders are trained, confident and clear on expectations.
Set clear goals, one step at a time
A common mistake is avoiding goals because “the role will evolve”. That uncertainty actually makes probation harder.
Instead, use staged goals. What should success look like at week 2, week 6, or month 3? Clear milestones reduce anxiety for new starters and make performance conversations fairer and easier.
Don’t mistake confidence for competence
Even experienced hires still need induction. Every workplace has different expectations, systems and unwritten rules.
Assuming someone will “just know” because they’ve done a similar job elsewhere can lead to frustration and misalignment - even at senior levels.
Be honest about the role and the reality
Great recruitment sets realistic expectations. While ads and position descriptions sell the opportunity, authenticity matters.
Be upfront about challenges, quirks and what success really looks like. That honesty should continue through probation. Transparency builds trust, not fear.
Give feedback early and often
Waiting until the end of probation to raise concerns is one of the biggest mistakes employers make.
Regular check-ins allow you to reinforce what’s working and address issues early - while there’s still time to course correct. No one should ever be surprised by a probation outcome.
Balance what’s legal with what’s fair
Probation periods and the Fair Work Act’s minimum employment period are not the same - and they shouldn’t be confused.
Strong employers align legal compliance with good people practice: clear expectations, genuine support, and fair, well-documented feedback.
Handle endings with dignity
Sometimes probation doesn’t work out and that’s okay.
When probation has been managed well, outcomes are clear, respectful and humane. Leaders should be able to confidently say: “We gave this every chance.” That makes all the difference.
Use probation to shape your culture
Probation is where people decide whether they’ve made the right choice - often within the first six weeks.
Clear expectations, regular feedback and supportive leadership send a powerful message about how things work around here. Treated well, probation becomes a competitive advantage, not just a compliance step.
The bottom line
Probation is where promises meet reality. Done well, it builds trust, capability and strong performance from day one. Done poorly, it quietly embeds disengagement and risk.
If you’d like help designing probation and induction frameworks that genuinely help leaders and set new starters up for success, our Partner Who Cares, Focus HR is able to help.
QFVG has been supporting horticultural growers with information and advice on workplace relations, human resource management and workplace health and safety for over 20 years. Today, we partner with consultants, and QFVG Partner Who Cares, Focus HR to deliver tailored and expert advice to our members.
Grower Members enjoy a range of benefits including:
Two hours complimentary workplace relations advice per year.
Discounts on all products in the Workplace Relations Shop and full range of services provided by Focus HR.
News & alerts on major industrial relations development delivered to your inbox.
Not a member? Join us today to unlock exclusive member benefits.
